Indirect optical manipulation of the antiferromagnetic order of insulating NiO by ultrafast interfacial energy transfer

summary

The gist

Indirect optical manipulation of the antiferromagnetic order of insulating NiO by ultrafast interfacial energy transfer reports an ultrafast…

In short

The study used ultrafast laser pulses to excite a Pt/NiO bilayer and observed a rapid loss of NiO's antiferromagnetic order within picoseconds. This loss is caused by energy transferring quickly from excited electrons in the Pt layer directly into the NiO spin system at their interface, mediated by exchange scattering. This shows how optical excitation can manipulate magnetic order below the material's bandgap.

Key concepts

Magneto-Optical Birefringence (MOBF)
MOBF is a signal measured during experiments that reflects the rhombohedral distortion of the NiO crystal lattice. Changes in this signal indicate changes in the magnetic structure, specifically how the NiO spins are ordered, allowing researchers to monitor magnetic dynamics over time.
Ultrafast Energy Transfer
This refers to a very fast process where energy moves from one system to another, happening on femtosecond or picosecond timescales. In this paper, it describes the rapid movement of energy from the hot electrons in the Pt layer into the NiO spin system across their interface.
Exchange Scattering
Exchange scattering is a specific type of interaction at an interface where electrons and spins interact directly. The paper proposes that this mechanism mediates the ultrafast energy transfer by coupling the excited electrons in platinum to the magnetic spins within the nickel oxide layer.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Indirect optical manipulation of the antiferromagnetic order of insulating NiO by ultrafast interfacial energy transfer · Read on arXiv

Stephan Wust, *, Christopher Seibel, Hendrik Meer, Paul Herrgen, Christin Schmitt, Lorenzo Baldrati, Rafael Ramos, Takashi Kikkawa, Eiji Saitoh, 6, 4, 7 Olena Gomonay,2 Jairo Sinova,2, 8 Yuriy Mokrousov,2, 9 Hans Christian Schneider, Mathias Klülaui, Baerbel Rethfeld, Benjamin Stadtmülller, * and Martin Aeschlimann1

Department of Physics and Research Center OPTIMAS at Technische Universität Kaiserslautern, Germany · Institute of Physics at Johannes Gutenberg-University Mainz, Germany · CIQUS at Universidade de Santiago de Compostela, Spain · WPI Advanced Institute for Materials Research at Tohoku University, Japan · Department of Applied Physics at The University of Tokyo, Japan · Institute for AI and Beyond at The University of Tokyo, Japan · Advanced Science Research Center at Japan Atomic Energy Agency, Tokai 319-1195, Japan · Institute of Physics at Czech Academy of Sciences

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Indirect optical manipulation of the antiferromagnetic order of insulating NiO by ultrafast interfacial energy transfer".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Indirect optical manipulation of the antiferromagnetic order of insulating NiO by ultrafast interfacial energy transfer reports an ultrafast, (sub)picosecond reduction of the antiferromagnetic order of the insulating NiO thin film in a Pt/NiO bilayer This reduction is attributed to an ultrafast and highly efficient energy transfer from the optically excited electron system of the Pt layer into the NiO spin system, proposed to be mediated by a stochastic exchange scattering at the Pt/NiO interface Experimental Setup and Observation The study utilizes an all-optical pump-probe setup employing an amplified Ti:Sapphire laser system with a 1.55 eV pump pulse duration of 35 fs to generate the pump and probe beams The magneto-optical birefringence (MOBF) signal, which reflects the rhombohedral distortion of the NiO crystal lattice, is monitored as a time-resolved response after optical excitation For the bare NiO thin film, no change in the transient MOBF signal was found after near-IR excitation because of its large bandgap of 4.3 eV However, for the Pt(2nm)/NiO bilayer structure, the MOBF signal significantly reduces on a femtosecond timescale followed by a slow relaxation on a picosecond timescale Mechanism of Energy Transfer The ultrafast energy transfer is attributed to an ultrafast energy transfer from the adjacent metallic platinum (Pt) layer that is strongly excited by the ultrashort near-IR pulse The authors propose that this ultrafast energy transfer occurs directly between the hot electron system of the metallic layer and the spin system of NiO, mediated by a stochastic exchange scattering at the interface This direct coupling is supported by temperature-based phenomenological simulations which show that the laser-heated electron system of Pt can couple directly to the phonons of insulating NiO The main interaction channel involves a direct interaction of the Pt electrons with the NiO spins described by an electron-spin coupling parameter σes Theoretical Modeling and Results The energy flow is described using a temperature-dependent phenomenological model, similar to the two-temperature model (TTM) The simulation involves coupling parameters such as gep, σes, gsp, and σpp to describe the dynamics of the metallic Pt layer and the spin system The model shows that the ultrafast energy transfer is mediated by a direct coupling between the Pt electron and NiO spin system at the interface within 500 fs to 1 ps The simulation reproduces the general trend observed experimentally, showing a fast, (sub-) picosecond reduction of the magnetic signal followed by a significantly slower relaxation of the magnetic order The joint experimental and theoretical study uncovered an incoherent ultrafast loss of the antiferromagnetic order of NiO after optical excitation with fs pulses in the near-IR range, occurring within the first ps after excitation The loss is attributed to an ultrafast energy transfer from the optically excited electron system in Pt directly into the antiferromagnetic spin system of NiO that depends on the coupling strength across the interface This work lays the foundation for manipulating magnetic order of insulating and semiconducting (antiferromagnetic) materials by interface engineering and optical excitation below the optical bandgap Identifying Magnon Modes The power spectrum analysis of the time-resolved MOBF traces revealed a clear peak around 133.5 GHz, which indicates the appearance of the low-frequency magnon mode in NiO This frequency very much resembles reported values for the low-frequency magnon mode in NiO The characteristic timescale of this energy transfer is directly reflected in the temperature evolution of the NiO spin system shown in Figure 3(b) The low-frequency magnon mode contributes to a coherent oscillation superimposed onto the incoherent MOBF signal Role of Interfacial Engineering The study demonstrates that introducing an insulating interlayer suppresses any interaction between the electron system of Pt and the electron or spin system of NiO, which substantially reduces the speed and efficiency of energy transfer from Pt into NiO In this case, excitation proceeds solely through phonon-phonon coupling, which is considerably slower than the direct electron-spin coupling This suppression allows the researchers to model the experimental data accurately The missing spin order in Pt causes a random exchange of angular momentum that results in an incoherent loss of magnetic order in NiO Modeling Discrepancies A discrepancy between the experimental and simulated MOBF traces is noted in the lineshape near the minimum of the magneto-optical contrast, which is particularly visible for larger fluences This systematically smaller reduction can be explained by the coherent oscillation signal of the low-frequency magnon mode (130 GHz) superimposed on the overall incoherent loss of MOBF Long-range collective spin-wave excitations can be driven on the sub-ps scale by laser-excited hot electrons The time constant of the loss of the antiferromagnetic order is between 0.5 and 1.0 ps, which is significantly longer than for a thin metallic ferromagnetic film Experimental Details The time-resolved experiments were performed with an all-optical pump-probe setup using an amplified Ti:Sapphire laser system (1.55 eV, 35 fs, 1 kHz, 7 mJ per pulse) to generate the pump and probe beams The probe was created by second-harmonic generation of the fundamental laser radiation with a Beta-Barium-Borate (BBO) crystal Both s-polarized pulses were focused on the sample under normal incidence (Angle relative to sample normal < 1 °) The total applied peak fluence was determined using the definition Φ = 2Pfπwxwy, where P represents the applied laser power and wx and wy are the corresponding 1/e2 spot-radii in x- and y-direction Model Parameters Optimization The four coupling parameters gep, σes, gsp and σpp were taken as independent on temperature These parameters were optimized in comparison with the experimental MOBF trace for an intermediate fluence of 1.19 mJ cm squared The coupling gep and σes mainly drive the height and time of the peak of the spin temperature Ts, while gsp is responsible for relaxation in the 10 ps range The energy loss to the substrate, described by σpp, acts on a longer range of ∼ 100 ps The resulting curves show a very good fit with the experimental data Final Conclusion In conclusion, the joint experimental and theoretical study uncovered an incoherent ultrafast loss of the antiferromagnetic order of NiO after optical excitation with fs pulses in the near-IR range The loss occurs within the first ps after optical excitation, attributed to an ultrafast energy transfer from the optically excited electron system in Pt directly into the antiferromagnetic spin system of NiO This ultrafast energy transfer is mediated by an exchange coupling between excited electrons in Pt and the NiO spins at the interface The work lays the foundation for the ultrafast manipulation of magnetic order of insulating and semiconducting (antiferromagnetic) materials by interface engineering and optical excitation below the optical bandgap Funding Acknowledgment The experimental work was funded by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation) - TRR 173 - 268565370 Spin + X: spin in its collective environment (Projects A01, A03, A08, A11, and B03) B.S.

Kai: further acknowledges funding by the Dynamics and Topology Research Center (TopDyn) funded by the State of Rhineland Palatinate R.R.

Mira: acknowledges support from the European Commission through the project 734187-SPICOLOST (H2020-MSCA-RISE-2016) and other grants The Xunta de Galicia (ED431B 2021/013, Centro Singular de Investigaci´on de Galicia Accreditation 2019-2022) and the European Union (European Regional Development Fund - ERDF) T.K.

Kai: and E.S.

Paper summary: Kai: So to wrap up this paper, what they found is an incoherent ultrafast loss of the antiferromagnetic order in nickel oxide within the first picosecond after you hit it with femtosecond pulses in the near-infrared range.

Mira: And that loss is directly caused by an ultrafast energy transfer from the hot electron system in platinum into the antiferromagnetic spin system of nickel oxide, and this depends on how strong that coupling is across their interface.

Lev: The main implication for us in hardware terms is that we need to consider those picosecond time constants when designing systems where magnetic order is crucial, because this loss lasts longer than it does in metallic ferromagnetic films.

Kai: They've shown a pathway for manipulating the magnetic order of insulating and semiconducting antiferromagnetic materials using interface engineering and optical excitation below the optical bandgap.

Mira: It’s a way to control magnetism by engineering the interface so that you can get that direct electron-spin coupling to be strong enough for ultrafast manipulation.

Lev: The work also points out that if you introduce an insulating interlayer, it suppresses this direct coupling and slows down the energy transfer significantly, which is useful information for designing systems where you want to prevent this rapid magnetic decay.

Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up this paper, they found an incoherent ultrafast loss of antiferromagnetic order in nickel oxide within the first picosecond after you hit it with femtosecond pulses in the near-infrared range.

Mira: And that loss is directly caused by an ultrafast energy transfer from the hot electron system in platinum into the antiferromagnetic spin system of nickel oxide, and this depends on how strong that coupling is across their interface.

Lev: The main implication for us in hardware terms is that we need to consider those picosecond time constants when designing systems where magnetic order is crucial, because this loss lasts longer than it does in metallic ferromagnetic films.

Kai: They've shown a pathway for manipulating the magnetic order of insulating and semiconducting antiferromagnetic materials using interface engineering and optical excitation below the optical bandgap.

Mira: It’s a way to control magnetism by engineering the interface so that you can get that direct electron-spin coupling to be strong enough for ultrafast manipulation.

Lev: The work also points out that if you introduce an insulating interlayer, it suppresses this direct coupling and slows down the energy transfer significantly, which is useful information for designing systems where you want to prevent this rapid magnetic decay.

Kai: They've essentially shown that you can use light to kick off a magnetic change in a material that wouldn't normally react so fast.

Mira: Because they are looking at NiO, which has a large bandgap, and they’re using near-infrared light, which is way below the optical cutoff.

Lev: That means we can do this manipulation without needing to hit it with high energy photons that might just heat up the whole structure indiscriminately.

Kai: The authors pinpoint an exchange coupling between those excited platinum electrons and the nickel oxide spins right at that interface as the main mechanism for this fast loss of order.

Mira: So, they are proposing that this specific electron-spin interaction is what drives the magnetic decay on a femtosecond to picosecond timescale.

Lev: From an error correction standpoint, knowing that this decoherence happens so fast in these oxide systems tells us exactly where we need to focus our coherence protection efforts in real hardware.

Kai: It lays the groundwork for manipulating magnetic order in insulators and semiconductors using optical excitation below the bandgap, which is pretty significant.

Mira: But they also noted a discrepancy in their simulation lineshape when they look at very high fluences, suggesting a coherent oscillation is masking part of the loss.

Lev: That means when we move to building actual devices, we have to be careful about that coherent magnon mode showing up and messing with our measurements.

Kai: It really opens up possibilities for controlling magnetism in things like spintronics using light rather than just magnetic fields or currents.

Mira: The next thing we need to look at is how much of that coupling strength actually changes the speed of the magnetic relaxation.

More episodes

← Home