Coexistence of Donor and Acceptor Hydrogen States in n-Type InN

summary

The gist

Hydrogen often exhibits amphoteric behavior in semiconductors, but its role is in n-type InN remains unresolved The coexistence of these opposite hydrogen charge states provides a microscopic picture…

In short

Researchers used HAXPES to study hydrogen states in InN films grown at different temperatures. They found evidence for coexisting acceptor H- and donor H+ charge states, providing a microscopic view of hydrogen compensation in n-type InN. Donor-like H+ is likely more stable and dominates conductivity.

Key concepts

HAXPES
Hard X-ray Photoemission Spectroscopy is a technique used to probe the electronic structure of materials. It has a probing depth much larger than conventional methods, making it less sensitive to surface effects and ideal for studying hydrogen states in thin films.
Acceptor H- state
This refers to an acceptor-like hydrogen impurity, likely located around In3+ sites. Its presence is suggested by spectral features indicating an occupied 1s2 state, contributing to the observed valence band spectral weight after annealing.
Donor H+ state
This is a donor-like hydrogen impurity associated with N3– sites. It is suggested by a negative component in the N 1s difference spectra and is considered more thermally stable than acceptor-like states, likely dominating the material's conductivity.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Coexistence of Donor and Acceptor Hydrogen States in n-Type InN · Read on arXiv

Basic Research Laboratories, NTT, Inc.

Hydrogen often exhibits amphoteric behavior in semiconductors, but its role is in n-type InN remains unresolved. Wurtzite InN is a narrow-gap semiconductor with high electron mobility and is therefore attractive for high-speed electronics and optoelectronic applications. Here we use hard x-ray photoemission spectroscopy (HAXPES) to probe hydrogen-related electronic structure in as-grown and post-annealed InN thin films prepared at different grown temperatures. Post annealing, which reduces the concentration of hydrogen impurities in the films, shifts the core-level spectra toward lower binding energy, consistent with a chemical-potential shift associated with the passivation of electron carriers. In the valence-band spectra, an acceptor-like in-gap feature near the valence-band maximum is suppressed after annealing. Together with the established donor-like behavior of hydrogen in InN, these results suggest that acceptor H- states coexist with donor H+ states in InN. The coexistence of these opposite hydrogen charge states provides a microscopic picture of hydrogen-driven compensation in InN and highlights the amphoteric nature of hydrogen even in a highly n-type semiconductor.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Coexistence of Donor and Acceptor Hydrogen States in n-Type InN".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Hydrogen often exhibits amphoteric behavior in semiconductors, but its role is in n-type InN remains unresolved The coexistence of these opposite hydrogen charge states provides a microscopic picture of hydrogen-driven compensation in InN and highlights the amphoteric nature of hydrogen even in a highly n-type semiconductor Probing Hydrogen States with HAXPES The researchers utilized hard x-ray photoemission spectroscopy (HAXPES) to investigate hydrogen-related electronic structure in as-grown and post-annealed InN thin films prepared at different growth temperatures HAXPES is well suited to this problem because its probing depth (l), on the order of several tenth nanometer, is much larger than that of conventional photoemission spectroscopy (PES) with laboratory X-ray sources (l 5 nm), making it substantially less sensitive to surface contributions The core-level spectra show that the post-annealing shifts the chemical potential in a direction consistent with compensating the residual electrons, even though the concentration of donor-like VN is slightly increased by annealing Evidence for Coexisting Charge States The results suggest that acceptor H– states coexist with donor H+ states in InN This coexistence of these opposite hydrogen charge states provides a microscopic picture of hydrogen-driven compensation in InN and highlights the amphoteric nature of hydrogen even in a highly n-type semiconductor The spectral-shape analysis identified an In–H-related component on the lower EB side of the In 3p spectra, suggesting an acceptor-like H– state located around the In3+ sites Furthermore, a negative component appeared above the main peak in the N 1s difference spectra, which is plausibly associated with donor-like H+ species located around the N3– sites Role of Annealing and Carrier Compensation Post-annealing reduces the H concentration from approximately 1021 to 1020 cm–3, and lowers the electron concentration n from the 1019 cm-3 to 1018 cm–3 range The reduction of the tail structures in the N 1s spectra is opposite to the enhancement of the higher EB components in the In 3p spectra, implying that annealing reduces an N-related component with a higher effective valence than N3– in InN These observations indicate that donor H+ impurities are likely to dominate the conductivity and more thermally stable than acceptor H– state in InN Thermal Stability and Dominant Species Thermochemical data suggest that NH3 is thermodynamically stable under standard conditions, whereas monomeric InH3 is much less stable and is discussed as a labile species This trend is qualitatively consistent with donor-like H associated with N-related environment being more thermally robust than acceptorlike H associated with In-related environment Donor H+ impurities are likely to dominate the conductivity and more thermally stable than acceptor H– state in InN The coexistence provides a more complete picture of hydrogen in InN than a donor-only description and points to hydrogen-driven compensation as an important part of the residual-carrier problem The existence of the acceptor impurities in an n-type semiconductor is plausible in light of the general tendency for charged impurities to compensate active carriers toward charge neutrality Donor-like H+ state is still likely to dominate the conductivity, consistent with previous studies of H impurity in InN The present HAXPES approach should be useful for disentangling defects and impurity-related states in semiconductors Schematic Summary of Findings The findings suggest the coexistence of minority acceptor H– state and majority donor H+ states in n-type InN thin films If hydrogen impurities can move relatively easily in InN, acceptor-like H– and donor-like H+ impurities may be stabilized near In3+ and N3– sites, respectively Only a few percent of the incorporated hydrogen appear to be electrically active, i.e., most of hydrogen remains electrically inactive Valence Band Structure Insights The in-gap spectral weight was obtained by subtracting the PA spectrum from the AG spectrum after accounting for the chemical-potential shift The in-gap spectral weight is suppressed by annealing, which is likely related to hydrogen-derived acceptor-like states In contrast to donor H+ (1s0), whose empty 1s state is not directly visible in photoemission, acceptor H– (1s2) is occupied and can contribute to the observed VB spectral weight The VBM was estimated by linear extrapolation of the VB leading edge, which was found to be around 1.2 eV for the Ts = 450 oC film Line Shape Analysis Details The difference spectra between the AG and PA films for In 3p3/2 and N 1s show distinct features related to these states The negative feature in the difference spectrum of the In 3p3/2 indicates a component that is suppressed by annealing, plausibly associated with an In–H bonding state The positive component above the main peak in the N 1s difference spectra is plausibly associated with donor-like H+ species located around the N3– sites This analysis indicates the coexistence of donor-like H+ and acceptor-like H– states in n-type InN The schematic summary suggests that acceptor-like H– and donor-like H+ impurities may be stabilized near In3+ and N3– sites, respectively The In 3p and N 1s peaks in the PA films shift systematically with Ts, in contrast to less shifts in the AG films, consistent with the Ts dependence of n The shifts reflect the chemical-potential shift associated with reduced electron concentration Both core levels in the PA films lie at lower EB than in the corresponding AG films, consistent with a chemical-potential shift toward the VBM and reduced n after annealing The results indicate that acceptor-like H– states, not expected to exist hitherto, coexist with donor-like H+ states in n-type InN Implications for Device Physics Because donor H+ appears to be more thermally stable than acceptor H– state, donor-like H+ state is still likely to dominate the conductivity, consistent with previous studies of H impurity in InN This picture suggests that hydrogen-driven compensation is an important part of the residual-carrier problem More broadly, the present HAXPES approach should be useful for disentangling defects and impurity-related states in semiconductors Schematic Summary of Results A unit cell of wurtzite InN is shown If hydrogen impurities can move relatively easily in InN, acceptor-like H– and donor-like H+ impurities may be stabilized near In3+ and N3– sites, respectively Only a few percent of the incorporated hydrogen appear to be electrically active, i.e., most of hydrogen remains electrically inactive The coexistence provides a more complete picture of hydrogen in InN than a donor-only description and points to hydrogen-driven compensation as an important part of the residual-carrier problem The relative N 1s intensity is nearly unchanged by annealing for films grown below 485 oC, but it decreases after annealing for films grown above 530 oC, even under the same annealing conditions This suggests that VN are more readily created at high Ts and are further increased by annealing The in-gap spectral weight decreases with increasing Ts, while the negative spectral weight likely reflects the reduced occupation of the conduction band after annealing This suppression of in-gap states is likely related to hydrogen-derived acceptor-like states The trend of n in Fig.

Paper summary: Kai: So, building on what we just said, this paper "Coexistence of Donor and Acceptor Hydrogen States in n-Type InN" is really focused on the idea that hydrogen has these dual roles in Indium Nitride.

Mira: They use hard x-ray photoemission spectroscopy to look at films grown at different temperatures to see how this affects the hydrogen states.

Kai: The main claim is that post-annealing shifts the corelevel spectra toward lower binding energy, which they link to a chemical potential shift related to passivating electron carriers.

Lev: They also found that in the valence band spectra, an acceptor like in gap feature near the valence band maximum gets suppressed after annealing.

Mira: This suppression of that acceptor-like feature is what ties into the idea of hydrogen-derived states influencing the spectral weight in the material.

Kai: The authors observed specific features: a negative component above the main peak in nitrogen one s difference spectra, and an In dash related component on the lower binding energy side of the Indium three p spectra.

Lev: That negative feature is what they associate with donor like H plus species located around those nitrogen three minus sites.

Mira: And that acceptor like feature is linked to H dash states situated near the indium three plus sites, which they are hypothesizing.

Kai: The authors also looked at the growth temperature dependence, seeing how the nitrogen one s intensity changes depending on whether the film was grown below or above five hundred thirty centimeters per cubic centimeter.

Lev: They found that those films grown above five hundred thirty centimeters per cubic centimeter actually have more vanadium defects created and those are further increased by annealing.

Mira: So, to put it plainly, the paper argues that the coexistence of donor and acceptor hydrogen states is a more complete picture than just describing it as donor only.

Kai: They suggest that if hydrogen moves easily in InN, these acceptor and donor like impurities might get stabilized near those specific Indium three plus and nitrogen three minus sites.

Lev: And they mention that only a few percent of the incorporated hydrogen actually appear to be electrically active, which means most of the hydrogen just stays inactive.

Conclusion: Kai: So, thinking about "Coexistence of Donor and Acceptor Hydrogen States in n-Type InN," the authors are basically saying we need to stop treating hydrogen as just one type of impurity when it’s in n-type Indium Nitride.

Mira: They aren't just adding a donor description; they’re showing how this duality is essential for understanding the residual carrier problem in these materials.

Kai: The implication for device physics is that because the donor state seems more thermally stable, we should still expect donor like H plus to be the main driver of conductivity.

Lev: That means when you design devices, you’re primarily dealing with a donor mechanism, but you have to account for these acceptor states as well because they exist.

Mira: It also suggests that hydrogen-driven compensation is a key part of how we solve the residual carrier problem in n-type InN.

Kai: And overall, this HAXPES approach gives us a better tool for disentangling all the different defects and impurity related states in these semiconductors.

More episodes

← Home