Coarse-graining dense, deformable active particles
summary
The gist
We coarse-grain a model of closely-packed ellipses that can vary their aspect ratio to derive continuum equations for materials comprising confluent deformable particles such as epithelial cell…
In short
The study coarse-grains closely-packed ellipses to create continuum equations for deformable materials like epithelial cell layers. It shows that contractile neighbor interactions and active hydrodynamic stresses cause cells to elongate and form nematic ordering, leading to active turbulence in extended systems.
Key concepts
- Anisotropy Tensor (W)
- This tensor describes the coarse-grained elongation of the particles. In two dimensions, it is a 2x2 symmetric, traceless matrix that captures both the magnitude and direction of how much an ellipse is stretched or compressed.
- Contractile Dipolar Stress ($\zeta_{a2}$)
- This term represents attractive interactions between neighboring ellipses. When this stress is negative, it acts to pull the particles together, which drives them toward elongation and nematic alignment through nearest-neighbor forces.
- Active Turbulence
- This phenomenon occurs when the system becomes unstable due to long-range flows in extended particles. This instability results in a chaotic flow field characterized by swirling motion and the formation of motile topological defects, similar to active liquid crystals.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Coarse-graining dense, deformable active particles · Paper Radio
- Collective rotational motion of freely-expanding T84 epithelial cell colonies
- Nonlinear spontaneous flow instability in active nematics
- Intercellular Friction and Motility Drive Orientational Order in Cell Monolayers
The paper
Coarse-graining dense, deformable active particles · Read on arXiv
Mehrana R. Nejad, Julia M. Yeomans
Department of Physics, Harvard University · The Rudolf Peierls Centre for Theoretical Physics, Department of Physics, University of Oxford
DOI: 10.1103/phtt-7db6
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Coarse-graining dense, deformable active particles".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We coarse-grain a model of closely-packed ellipses that can vary their aspect ratio to derive continuum equations for materials comprising confluent deformable particles such as epithelial cell layers We show that contractile nearest neighbour interactions between ellipses can lead to their elongation and nematic ordering Adding flows resulting from active hydrodynamic stresses produced by the particles also affects the aspect ratio and can result in active turbulence Our results, which agree well with multi-phase field simulations of deformable isotropic cells, provide a bridge between models which explicitly resolve cells and continuum theories of active matter Model Formulation and Variables The coarse-graining involves considering a confluent system and working in terms of the coarse-grained variables W and A W is the anisotropy tensor which, in two dimensions, is a 2 × 2 symmetric, traceless tensor that describes the coarse-grained magnitude and direction of particle elongation A is a variable describing the locally averaged particle area Each of the hydrodynamic variables X = X˙ f + X˙ I + X˙ u obeys an equation of motion of the form ∂tX = X˙ f + X˙ I + X˙ u The internal active nematic stress for the particle i can be written as πsi = −ζ a1 a−1diφi(x) This term is referred to as the self-interaction The contractile dipolar stress, ζ a2 < 0, acts between overlapping neighbours j of ellipse i as πni = −ζ a2 Xj≠i djφj (x) Dynamics of Shape and Area The dynamics of the phase field is given by φ˙ i = −f aiΓ · ∇φi Using Eqs.
Kai: (6) and (7), the Gaussian form (2) chosen for the particle shape then allows an analytic calculation of the time evolution of the anisotropy tensor (3) The dynamics of the field are given by w˙ i = −(αiwi + ¯αi ˜wi), where ˜wi = Pj≠i wj, αi = −8π/2 ζ a1 /(27Γai) and α = -8π/2 ζ a1 /(27ΓA0) The area dynamics is given by a˙ i = ciwi: wi + ¯ciwi: ˜wi, where ci = −π/4 ζ a1 /(32a 2i Γ), and ¯c = π/4 ζ a2 /(32a 2i Γ) Competition Between Active and Passive Forces The equations of motion for particle shape an area are W˙ = ΓWKW − αr¯20/2 ∇2W − (¯α + α + ΓWCW(1 + W: W))W The first term in Eq.
Mira: (18) defines an effective elastic constant ΓWKW − αr¯20/2 This becomes negative for sufficiently large and positive active interactions between ellipses, destabilising any nematic alignment and suggesting that the nematogens prefer to align perpendicular to each other Sufficiently negative α and ¯α destabilise the isotropic shape and lead to a homogeneous steady state solution for the elongation Wst given by W2st = −(¯α + α) / ΓWCW The homogeneous steady state area Ast then follows from Eq.
Kai: (19): Ast = A0 + (¯c + c/2)ΓACA W2st Long-Range Flows and Active Turbulence The evolution of W is very similar to the dynamics of a nematic liquid crystal in an isotropic phase and with a positive flow aligning parameter λ = 1 For sufficiently extended particles, there is an active instability and the nematic state becomes unstable, giving rise to active turbulence, characterised by a chaotic flow field and motile topological defects The phase diagram shows three different phases: a stationary isotropic phase, a stationary nematic phase and an active phase with non-zero velocity and defect formation For (˜α+α)/(ΓW CW) > −1 the cells remain isotropic and the velocity is zero unless ζ is sufficiently large and positive, when the extensional flows can elongate the particles to give a nematic state As (˜α + α)/(ΓW CW) decreases from −1, short-range forces between neighbours elongate the particles to give a nematic state, with hydrodynamic flows tending to enhance or suppress the elongation for ζ > 0 or ζ < 0, respectively For sufficiently extended particles, there is an active instability and the nematic state becomes unstable, giving rise to active turbulence By coarse-graining a model of closely-packed ellipses that can vary their aspect ratio we have derived continuum equations for confluent deformable particles, an important example of which is epithelial cell layers We show that contractile neighbour interactions, modelling the effects of actin filaments and stress fibers, compete with cell self contractility, and cause collective cell elongation and, when flows are permitted, form ±1/2 defects Our results reproduce many of the features seen in multi-phase field models which resolve the boundaries of individual cells including cell extension by neighbour interactions and changes in cell size The simplicity of the model suggests the possibility of studying how, for example, traction forces, active line tension, or different particle symmetries could be included in a continuum model of deformable particles Acknowledgements We thank Guanming Zhang, Delia Cropper, Ioannis Hadjifrangiskou, James Graham, and Sumesh Thampi for helpful discussions JMY acknowledges support from the UK EPSRC (Award EP/W023849/1) and ERC Advanced Grant ActBio (funded as UKRI Frontier Research Grant EP/Y033981/1) References
1: D.
Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper called "Coarse-graining dense, deformable active particles." It's about taking a model of closely packed ellipses that can change their shape and aspect ratio and turning it into continuum equations for materials like epithelial cell layers.
Mira: That’s right. The authors show how contractile nearest neighbour interactions between these ellipses can actually cause them to elongate and start forming some kind of nematic ordering. It’s a big step because it bridges the gap between models that look at individual cells and the continuum theories we use for active matter in general.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, what excites me is how they get those equations of motion for the shape tensor, specifically seeing something like w dot i equals negative alpha i w i plus beta i tilde w i where tilde w is related to the neighbors' shapes. That’s actually a very concrete dynamic equation.
Kai: Exactly. And they also look at how adding flows, those active hydrodynamic stresses produced by the particles, messes with the aspect ratio and can lead to what they call active turbulence. That suggests a whole new way of thinking about how these materials move collectively under stress.
Mira: They show that the results actually agree pretty well with multi-phase field simulations of deformable isotropic cells, which is a strong validation for their coarse-graining approach. It proves that this continuum description captures the essential physics when you look at those deformable systems.
Lev: But we need to be careful about what they assume there. They linearize in the particle anisotropy and area change and then assume overdamped dynamics while ignoring passive forces for now, which is a simplification we'd have to check on real hardware.
Kai: Right, so they use some specific coefficients for the self-interaction stress and the contractile dipolar stress. The self-interaction term involves zeta a one over alpha i, and the neighbor interaction uses zeta a two as negative.
Mira: And that negative sign for zeta a two is crucial because it means those contractile interactions favor elongation, which is what leads to that nematic ordering they're describing. It’s the driving force behind the shape change here.
Title and authors: Lev: If you look at the area dynamics, a dot a i equals constant times w i dot plus something related to tilde w, which means the cell area changes based on its current shape and how its neighbors are oriented. That coupling between shape and area is what makes it complex.
Kai: And they derive a homogeneous steady state solution for the elongation, which they call w star star, given by that expression involving alpha and beta divided by gamma w c w minus one. That gives us a specific equilibrium state for the cell elongation under those active stresses.
Mira: That steady state area also follows from an equation that involves a constant c i and another constant bar c i, which relates the area to the anisotropy tensor at that point. It links all these different physical quantities together in one picture.
Lev: From a real hardware perspective, getting that level of precision for those coefficients would require incredibly stable measurements of the particle interactions, especially for things like zeta a one and zeta a two. That’s where we need to focus our error correction efforts if we were trying to build something based on this continuum theory.
Kai: So what they really show is that contractile neighbour interactions compete with cell self contractility, and that competition drives the collective elongation, which then creates these defects when flows are allowed. That's a key physical mechanism they highlight in the paper "Coarse-graining dense, deformable active particles".
Mira: And when you consider the active flows themselves—the hydrodynamic stresses—they can either enhance or suppress that elongation depending on whether zeta is positive or negative, which is a very interesting dependency. It shows how external fluid motion interacts with internal cellular activity.
Lev: The part about active turbulence resulting from sufficiently extended particles and the instability in the nematic state is interesting because it means that under certain conditions, we don't get a simple ordered state; we get chaos instead. That would be tough to model on real systems if you aren't careful with those instabilities.
Title and authors: Kai: So, what they are really doing here is providing a bridge. They give us continuum theories of active matter that match the results from simulations that explicitly resolve individual cells, which is pretty powerful for testing our models. It’s like having both the microscopic and macroscopic view talking to each other through this model "Coarse-graining dense, deformable active particles".
Mira: It suggests that we can use these continuum descriptions to predict collective behavior in complex biological tissues, like those epithelial layers they mention. But of course, it doesn't tell us how the actual actin filaments or stress fibers are generating those exact forces.
Lev: And that's a limitation you have to keep in mind—the paper states that for now, they are ignoring passive forces in their dynamics equations, which is a big assumption when you think about real cells where passive viscosity and stiffness play huge roles. That’s where the real work would be if we were translating this to something physical.
Kai: So to wrap up on "Coarse-graining dense, deformable active particles," the paper successfully derives continuum equations that show how neighbour interactions cause elongation and how flows can induce turbulence in these deformable particles. It connects microscopic details to macroscopic flow patterns, which is what we needed.
Mira: And it gives us a framework for understanding collective cell behavior by showing the interplay between internal contractile forces and external fluid stresses. It’s a solid piece of work that brings together different scales of physics into one set of equations.
Lev: For me, the main thing is seeing how the active instability leads to active turbulence; that's where things get messy and non-linear, which is exactly what you want to see in complex biological systems. It sets a target for what kind of chaotic dynamics we should expect to measure if we were building a system that exhibited this behavior.
Kai: So we’ve covered the title, the core findings about contraction versus flow effects, and how it links simulations to continuum theories with this paper "Coarse-graining dense, deformable active particles." We’re going to take a quick break and then look at some other stuff.
The paper's summary: Kai: So what we’re talking about is how the authors took this really detailed model of densely packed, deformable ellipses and simplified it down to these continuum equations for materials like epithelial cell layers.
Mira: Exactly. The main point they’re making is that when you look at those closely packed particles, there are two competing forces at play: the self-interaction of each particle and the contractile stress between neighboring ones.
Kai: They found that this contractile neighbor interaction actually drives the particles to get longer, leading to this nematic ordering, which is a sort of collective alignment.
Mira: And then they showed that if you introduce hydrodynamic flows—those active stresses from the particles moving through a fluid—that flow can further change how elongated those particles are.
Kai: It means the flow isn't just passive; it actively participates in shaping the cell layer dynamics, and sometimes that leads to active turbulence.
Mira: That’s important because it gives us a way to see how internal cellular activity and external fluid movement interact on the same scale.
Lev: For me, what they’re really doing is providing a bridge between those microscopic simulations of individual cells and the macroscopic theories we use for active matter.
Kai: They state that their continuum equations agree pretty well with multi-phase field simulations of deformable isotropic cells, which is a big win for validating the approach.
Mira: It means this coarse-grained model captures some of the essential physics when you compare it to those more explicit cell models, including how neighbors influence each other and how size changes over time.
Lev: The next thing we need to look at is how these equations would actually run on real hardware, because getting those coefficients right for things like the self-interaction stress is going to be tricky.
Kai: Right, so the paper sets up a framework that lets us study collective behavior in complex biological tissues by seeing how internal forces fight against external fluid stresses.
Mira: It’s about understanding that interplay between contractile forces and active flows, which is really what drives the elongation and the potential for turbulence in these systems.
Lev: It also gives us a starting point for thinking about how things might change if we introduce other factors, like traction forces or different particle shapes into this continuum model.
The paper's improvements: Tom: So we’re looking at how the authors suggest ways to make this model better, and they are pointing out some key areas for improvement in "Coarse-graining dense, deformable active particles."
Kai: They suggest incorporating shape-changing and short-range interactions in a way that mirrors using a Landau de Gennes free energy from fixed particle shape models.
Mira: That’s interesting because it suggests we should look at how the local order of the particle isn't just averaged out, but how it changes dynamically based on its immediate surroundings.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, that would mean we need a more detailed way to model those short-range forces, which will definitely increase the computational overhead for any simulation we build on this.
Kai: They also point out that they could derive the equations of motion for the shape tensor by looking at both internal forces and how those nearest neighbor interactions affect it directly.
Mira: And that leads to a specific equation like w dot i equals negative alpha i w i plus beta i tilde w i, which gives us a clearer picture of how the orientation changes over time based on local neighbors.
Lev: That’s useful because it moves us away from just looking at bulk properties and towards modeling the actual local interactions that would be necessary for real hardware.
Kai: They also show that they could analyze how active and passive forces combine by solving those coupled equations for particle shape and area simultaneously.
Mira: This is crucial because it means we can see exactly how the cell's shape evolves based on both what's happening inside it and what its neighbors are doing.
Lev: That coupling is what makes the dynamics complex, but if we could get that right, it would give us a much more accurate picture of the system’s behavior under stress.
Kai: The overall implication here is that by adding these improvements, we can get a much richer description of how these materials move and organize themselves collectively.
Mira: It suggests the next step for this research is figuring out exactly what kind of forces—like traction or active line tension—we should include to make the model truly predictive for biological tissues.
Lev: Right, so they’re basically saying, if we want this to be useful for real systems, we need to get these microscopic details right and see how much computational power that will actually take.
Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, this paper "Coarse-graining dense, deformable active particles" shows how we can take a complex model of packing ellipses and turn it into simple continuum equations for things like epithelial cell layers.
Mira: It really lays out that those contractile neighbor interactions drive the elongation, and when you add hydrodynamic flows, they can lead to active turbulence.
Lev: I just think the biggest implication is that this gives us a concrete way to test if these ideas hold up on real systems, which is what we need for error correction models.
Kai: Exactly. It bridges the gap between those detailed microscopic simulations of individual cells and the big picture continuum theories we use for active matter.
Mira: It shows how internal forces fighting against external fluid stresses create collective cell elongation and those dynamic flow patterns we see in nature.
Lev: If you want to run this on actual hardware, you’re going to need extremely stable measurements for those interaction coefficients, which is the caveat we have to keep in mind.
Kai: Right, so the work on "Coarse-graining dense, deformable active particles" gives us a solid mathematical structure that connects cellular mechanics to fluid dynamics.
Mira: It opens up a lot of possibilities for modeling how things organize themselves under stress without needing to track every single particle individually.
Lev: For my side, it’s an interesting problem because the non-linear flow part is where the complexity lands when you try to map this onto a real physical system.
More episodes
- 2610.32678-Probing the limits of materials design via a comprehensive crystal database of 14.6 million structures with 140 properties
- 2610.33595-Native-oxide-driven layer asymmetry, two-step switching and exchange bias in Co/Ir/Co trilayers
- 2503.19572-Spin models from nonlinear cellular automata
- 2606.23350-Irreversibility Enhances Quantum-Enhanced Markov-Chain Monte Carlo
- 2608.02744-Two-Parameter Ansatz for the Violation of Eigenstate Thermalization
- 2210.00806-Low- and high-energy localization landscapes for tight-binding Hamiltonians in two-dimensional lattices
- 2409.09625-Selective switch for band-edge alignments in pentagonal CdSeTe monolayer: Atom-valley locking
- 2606.20168-Norms, overlaps and Yangian descendants for the Haldane-Shastry spin chain
- 2512.19503-Strain-induced splitting of the CCDW-NCCDW phase transition in 1T-TaS 2
- 2307.12638-Strong localization of microwaves beyond two dimensions in aperiodic Vogel spirals