High-Level Synthesis of Efficient Pipelines with Visibility Control

summary

The gist

High-level synthesis (HLS) raises the abstraction of hardware design from concurrent register-transfer level (RTL) programs to sequential programs <ref:2607.18765#pg2> Among the forms of parallelism…

In short

The paper introduces an HLS tool that embeds fine-grained pipeline control directly into a sequential programming model. It uses 'visibility control' as an abstraction to unify different hazard resolution strategies, allowing designers to rapidly explore pipeline structures while maintaining sequential semantics. This enables the creation of high-performance hardware designs with competitive power and area against hand-written RTL.

Key concepts

High-Level Synthesis (HLS)
HLS is a method that translates high-level code, like C++ or Rust, into hardware description languages for chips. The paper focuses on HLS tools that can handle complex pipelining—a technique where multiple operations happen in stages—by giving the programmer fine control over how these stages interact.
Visibility Control
This is a new programming abstraction that simplifies hazard resolution. It lets the designer choose what data an earlier instruction makes available and how a later instruction should react to that data. This choice unifies various complex pipeline strategies into simple programming decisions.
Sequential Programming Model
Instead of writing code that describes concurrent hardware, this model uses standard sequential programming structures. The tool maps these sequential programs into pipelines by using specific abstractions like 'speculative loop pipelining' and 'Var' controls to manage the pipeline structure and hazards.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

High-Level Synthesis of Efficient Pipelines with Visibility Control · Read on arXiv

KAIST · Seoul National University · FuriosaAI

High-level synthesis (HLS) raises the abstraction of hardware design from concurrent register-transfer level (RTL). Among the forms of parallelism HLS exploits, pipelining demands fine-grained control over pipeline structure and hazard resolution to achieve competitive power, performance, and area (PPA). However, existing tools either lack such control or sacrifice sequential semantics to provide it. We present an HLS tool that embeds fine-grained pipeline control in a sequential programming model while generating synchronization logic only where needed to resolve the pipeline's potential hazards. The tool builds on visibility control, a novel programming abstraction that unifies hazard resolution techniques including stalling, bypassing, speculation, deferred commit, and register renaming. We evaluate on in-order RISC-V cores, histograms, and an AES accelerator. On RISC-V cores, we implement stall, bypass, speculation, and register renaming; on histograms, we implement scheduling strategies that previously required RTL or concurrent programming models. Compiled pipelines outperform HLS tools with sequential semantics and achieve PPA comparable to hand-written RTL.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Computer Science. The day in computer science: software, systems and theory on arXiv.

Tom: We're looking at the paper: "High-Level Synthesis of Efficient Pipelines with Visibility Control".

Jane: Here's the gist of the paper. High-level synthesis (HLS) raises the abstraction of hardware design from concurrent register-transfer level (RTL) programs to sequential programs <ref:2607.18765#pg2> Among the forms of parallelism HLS exploits, pipelining demands fine-grained control over pipeline structure and hazard resolution to achieve competitive power, performance, and area (PPA) <ref:2607.18765#pg4>.

Tom: We present an HLS tool that embeds fine-grained pipeline control in a sequential programming model, enabling rapid design-space exploration <ref:2607.18765#pg5>.

Jane: The Problem with Existing Tools Existing HLS tools either lack such control or sacrifice sequential semantics to provide it <ref:2607.18765#pg2>.

Tom: Traditional HLS tools keep sequential semantics but give up fine-grained control over the pipelining strategy <ref:2607.18765#pg4>.

Title and authors: Tom: So, this paper is called "High-Level Synthesis of Efficient Pipelines with Visibility Control". It sounds technical, but the authors are trying to take hardware design away from those complicated concurrent register-transfer level programs and move it into something sequential.

Jane: That's the core idea. They want to make designing hardware pipelines easier by letting you write code that looks more like a normal sequential program, but still get that fine-grained control over how the pipeline is structured and how hazards are handled.

Lu: It’s about using this concept to explore different pipeline strategies really fast, like stalling or bypassing, all within one sequential programming model.

Meng: But existing tools either don't have that level of control or they give up the sequential semantics to get it, which is a big trade-off.

Lalam: Basically, this paper introduces this new abstraction called visibility control to unify how you resolve hazards across different pipeline strategies like stalling, bypassing, speculation, and register renaming.

The paper's summary: Tom: So what’s the actual mechanism they propose? They introduce visibility control as a unified programming abstraction for hazard resolution. This abstraction boils down every hazard resolution strategy into two choices: what an earlier instruction exposes about its pending reads and writes on shared state, and how a later instruction reacts to that exposure.

Jane: That’s a really neat way to frame it because it lets you pick from four different dimensions of hazard resolution—per-state resolution, policy selection, per-address resolution, or picking an observation stage—which is much more flexible than what we see in other tools.

Lu: They build their model on speculative loop pipelining where each loop iteration overlaps with the next one. Then they resolve dependency hazards using this visibility control primitive called Var. And they also capture advisory state, like a branch predictor, through SpecVar, which doesn't need any hazard resolution at all because it doesn't affect correctness.

Meng: I’m interested in how they handle the actual implementation of this control. It sounds like they are putting this control into a sequential model that lets you have fine-grained pipelining strategy control.

Lalam: They instantiate visibility control in a sequential programming model that gives you fine-grained pipeline strategy control, and they use three abstractions: speculative loop pipelining for structure, Var for hazard resolution per variable, and SpecVar for advisory state like a branch history table.

The paper's improvements: Tom: The main improvement they show is that this model allows you to explore pipelining strategies while keeping the sequential semantics, which is something existing tools either lack or sacrifice. They claim this enables rapid design-space exploration.

Jane: They show that by using this approach, you can achieve competitive power, performance, and area PPA across three different case studies: in-order RISC-V cores, countif histograms, and an AES accelerator.

Lu: On the RISC-V cores specifically, they implemented stall, bypass, speculation and register renaming all using this model. The results show that their designs are one point two to one point eight times lower runtime and one point seven to three point nine times smaller area compared to PDL’s designs under static prediction or renaming strategies.

Meng: That comparison against PDL is significant because PDL fragments hazard resolution across different subsystems, which seems to be the weakness they are addressing by unifying it all in this one model.

Jane: And on the countif histograms, their designs match or exceed Kanagawa’s PPA across static, dynamic, and speculative hazard resolution strategies. That means they're keeping up with those concurrent tools on complex workloads.

Conclusion: Tom: So to wrap up the paper "High-Level Synthesis of Efficient Pipelines with Visibility Control," the main implication is that this sequential programming model lets you get fine-grained control over pipeline structure while still being able to rapidly explore different strategies like stalling or bypassing.

Jane: It’s about having a unified abstraction, visibility control, that lets you pick how to resolve hazards—whether it's per-variable resolution or policy selection—and then the compiler handles the rest efficiently by specializing each variable's hazard resolution for your chosen strategy.

Lu: The paper formalizes this pipeline behavior and sketches a proof of compiler correctness, showing that the pipeline actually refines the source program up to base-state commits. They show how this works across those three case studies, achieving competitive PPA against hand-written RTL.

Meng: For production work, it’s good that they show you can generate high-performance CPUs like RISC-V cores that are significantly smaller and faster than PDL designs without needing the complexity of register renaming.

Lalam: From my view, this paper shows how declarative instruction level parallelism support under sequential semantics can be achieved by separating the policy from the mechanism, letting you adjust your PPA tradeoffs directly.

More episodes

← Home