Euclid Data Release 1 (DR1). Persistence in NISP detectors

summary

The gist

Detector persistence is a significant source of systematic error in infrared observations and affects the scientific performance of the Euclid Near Infrared Spectrometer and Photometer (NISP).

In short

This work characterizes detector persistence, a systematic error in infrared observations, using both ground calibration and in-flight data. It develops two empirical models to describe how this error changes over time and space across detectors. The findings inform mitigation strategies for data processing pipelines.

Key concepts

Persistence
Persistence is a non-uniform systematic error in detectors where the response to a signal depends on previous signals. It varies greatly across the focal plane and can be as large as two orders of magnitude, affecting scientific measurements.
Model Parameterization
Two models are used to describe persistence: one based on ground data (fast component) and another based on in-flight data (long-term evolution). These models help capture the different temporal behaviors of the error across various observation timescales.
Mitigation Strategy
A dynamic masking strategy is proposed to reduce visible persistence artifacts. This involves combining a fixed illumination history duration, such as three hours, with a specific signal threshold to mask pixels effectively while minimizing data loss.
Signal Dependence
The magnitude and decay rate of persistence depend nonlinearly on the input signal level. Brighter signals induce faster decay rates for the persistence effect compared to weaker stimuli.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Euclid Data Release 1 (DR1). Persistence in NISP detectors · Read on arXiv

B. Kubik, S. Conseil, R. Barbier, S. Ferriol, C. Macabiau, R. Kohley, P. Awad, A. Bonchi

ESO

Detector persistence is a significant source of systematic error in infrared observations and affects the scientific performance of the Near Infrared Spectrometer and Photometer (NISP). We characterise persistence using complementary ground calibration and in-flight data, develop empirical models of its temporal evolution, and assess its impact on science observations and the data-processing pipeline. Persistence is highly non-uniform across the focal plane, with variations of up to two orders of magnitude between and within detectors. Its amplitude is typically below 1% of the stimulus signal and depends nonlinearly on the preceding fluence. The decay rate is faster for brighter sources. During mission operations, the persistence signal has progressively decreased by roughly 10%, while the decay rate has remained approximately stable. Persistence following over-saturating signals does not follow the empirical relations derived for under-saturating fluences and plausibly reduces persistence response over longer timescales. The impact of charge trapping and release on flat-field observations and on the background in science exposures is also discussed. Persistence measured in science observations is observed to differ systematically from that derived from dark calibration data. In addition, persistence of energetic particle hits is observed to be different from that of astronomical sources of comparable signal. Finally, we discuss the impact of persistence on NISP observations and describe the masking strategy adopted for the Q1 abd DR1 releases, focusing on identifying which pixels are affected by persistence and for how long they should be excluded from science observations.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics. The day in astrophysics: observations, models and what the data forces.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Euclid Data Release 1 (DR1). Persistence in NISP detectors".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Detector persistence is a significant source of systematic error in infrared observations and affects the scientific performance of the Euclid Near Infrared Spectrometer and Photometer (NISP).

Vera: Persistence is highly non-uniform across the focal plane, with variations of up to two orders of magnitude between and within detectors.

Jocelyn: Its amplitude is typically below 1% of the stimulus signal and depends nonlinearly on the preceding fluence.

Vera: The decay rate is faster for brighter sources.

Title and authors: Vera: So, we're looking at this paper, "Euclid Data Release one (DR1) <ref:2611.16766#pg1,Euclid Data Release 1 (DR1>. Persistence in NISP detectors," and it tackles how much noise comes from the detectors themselves in these infrared observations.

Jocelyn: It points out that persistence is a big systematic error source for the Euclid Near Infrared Spectrometer and Photometer, and it's not uniform at all across the focal plane—it can vary by two orders of magnitude between different detectors or even within the same detector itself.

Subrahmanyan: That non-uniformity suggests we can't treat persistence as a single correction factor for all data; it really depends on where you are looking in the sky, and that's a big deal for structure formation studies.

Vera: Exactly. The paper says the amplitude of this persistence effect is usually below one percent of the signal you're actually measuring, and it’s tied nonlinearly to how much light came before it—the preceding fluence.

Jocelyn: And the decay rate itself changes; it decays faster when you look at brighter sources because that suggests a brighter stimulus causes a quicker loss of coherence in the signal.

Subrahmanyan: From a cosmological standpoint, if this persistence varies so much, our ability to measure faint signals from distant galaxies will be highly dependent on which detector is observing them, and we need to know how this changes the error bars for things like galaxy clustering.

Vera: The authors are using ground calibration data alongside in-flight data to build empirical models of this temporal evolution, which is a clever way to track how persistence changes over time during the mission.

Jocelyn: They use two different ways to model it: one based on ground measurements that gives them high precision but only shows the fast decay component, and another based on in-flight data that tracks the signal over longer timescales, maybe around an hour.

Subrahmanyan: That difference in timescale is important because it means we have a very precise picture of what happens quickly versus what happens over a longer period when we look at sustained signals.

Vera: They also map out this spatial distribution across the focal plane, showing how the persistence varies not just between detectors but even between individual pixels inside one detector.

Title and authors: Jocelyn: And they use an empirical model to describe that amplitude dependence on the prior signal level, which they call alpha, and a decay rate dependent on that signal level, which they call beta.

Subrahmanyan: So, if a source is very bright, you expect a fast decay because of the 'brighter-faster' effect they mentioned in their description. That’s something we need to factor into our forecasts for how much noise we can tolerate in our cosmological constraints.

Vera: Now, let's talk about how this affects the actual science data processing pipeline, which is where things get practical.

Jocelyn: The paper explains that the impact depends on what you are doing; for instance, when they were doing Q1 processing, they only considered that fast-decay component over short timescales.

Subrahmanyan: That suggests a trade-off between speed and accuracy in their early stages of data handling, which is something we need to keep in mind when planning how we extract information from the raw data.

Vera: For later processing, like DR1, they accounted for up to five hours of preceding exposures and included spectroscopic targets, showing a more comprehensive look at the persistence issue.

Jocelyn: It sounds like the whole point is that persistence isn't just noise; it's a time-dependent artifact that needs different handling depending on whether you’re doing fast photometry or deep spectroscopy.

Subrahmanyan: If we can properly model this temporal evolution, it should allow us to get more reliable measurements of cosmological parameters like the Hubble constant, but the uncertainty will come from how well we apply these models.

Vera: So, they propose some mitigation strategies based on masking thresholds and how long you include in your illumination history model.

Jocelyn: They found that a three-hour illumination history combined with a signal threshold of about five electrons gives a good balance, reducing the masked fraction down to below about five percent while still successfully suppressing those visible persistence artifacts.

Subrahmanyan: That threshold sounds like it's what we need to aim for in our pipelines—a compromise that keeps most of the signal while cutting out the most problematic noise.

Vera: The authors also point out some interesting differences between persistence measured in science observations and what you get from dark calibration data, which suggests they aren't identical.

Title and authors: Jocelyn: They also found that energetic particle hits, or EPHs, produce signals with lower amplitudes and faster decay compared to astronomical sources at similar signal levels.

Subrahmanyan: That’s significant because it means we can potentially use the persistence signal itself as a tool to help us distinguish between astrophysical sources and these particle events during data analysis.

Vera: And they also observed that over the mission, the overall amplitude of this persistence signal has gradually decreased by roughly ten percent, which they link to repeated exposure of pixels to highly saturating stimuli.

Jocelyn: That gradual long-term decrease in amplitude is something we need to track, because it tells us about the cumulative effects on detector performance over time as the mission progresses.

Subrahmanyan: If that trend continues, we might need a way to recalibrate persistence after oversaturations, because they noted that these events can induce long-lasting changes in persistence that could last for months with little temporal evolution.

Vera: So, to wrap up this paper on "Euclid Data Release one (DR1) <ref:2611.16766#pg1,Euclid Data Release 1 (DR1>. Persistence in NISP detectors," we see a complex, spatially varying noise source tied to the preceding signal level and time.

Jocelyn: The key practical takeaway is that you need a flexible approach to modeling this decay, using both ground calibration and in-flight data to cover different timescales.

Subrahmanyan: And for the community, it means we have a better handle on the systematic uncertainties inherent in these infrared observations, which should help us get more robust constraints on cosmology.

Vera: We’ll keep an eye on how this model performs as we continue our science runs and see if those mitigation strategies actually cut that masked fraction down to the five percent level they mentioned.

Jocelyn: And we're eager to see how this persistence signal plays out when we start looking at those deeper, longer-term observations where the in-flight data model becomes most relevant.

Subrahmanyan: It’s a good piece of work because it moves beyond just measuring the noise and gives us a concrete way to handle it, which is what we need to keep pushing for better constraints on dark energy or structure formation.

The paper's summary: Vera: So, we’re talking about how the Euclid Near Infrared Spectrometer and Photometer has persistence issues in its data release one, or DR1.

Jocelyn: Right, so that persistence is this noise that sticks around after a signal changes, and it's a huge systematic error source for the whole mission.

Vera: Exactly. The paper says this isn't uniform across the detector array; you get variations of up to two orders of magnitude between different detectors or even between individual pixels in one detector.

Jocelyn: It’s really non-uniform, which means we can’t just apply one simple correction to everything across the sky.

Vera: The amplitude of this persistence effect is usually below one percent of the actual signal you're measuring, and it depends on how much light came before it.

Jocelyn: And the decay rate itself changes; a brighter source causes that persistence to die off faster than a dimmer one.

Vera: They characterized this using ground calibration data and in-flight data to build two different models of its temporal evolution.

Jocelyn: One model uses ground measurements for high precision but only shows the fast decay component, while the other uses in-flight data to track it over longer timescales, maybe around an hour.

Vera: That difference is important because it tells us how persistence behaves on different timescales during the mission.

Jocelyn: They also mapped out this spatial distribution across the focal plane, showing how it varies between detectors and even within pixels.

Vera: The authors use an empirical model to describe that amplitude dependence and decay rate dependence based on the signal level you put in.

Jocelyn: So, if a source is very bright, you expect that fast decay because of this relationship they found.

Vera: Now, how does this affect the actual science data processing pipeline?

Jocelyn: The impact depends entirely on what you are doing; for example, early processing only looked at the fast-decay component over short timescales.

Vera: But later processing, like DR1, accounted for up to five hours of preceding exposures and included spectroscopic targets.

Jocelyn: It seems they are saying that persistence isn't just a simple noise bump; it’s a time-dependent artifact that needs different handling depending on whether you are doing fast photometry or deep spectroscopy.

Vera: And they propose mitigation strategies based on masking thresholds and how long you include in your illumination history model.

Jocelyn: They found that a three-hour illumination history combined with a signal threshold of about five electrons gives a good balance, reducing the masked fraction down to below about five percent while still suppressing those visible artifacts.

Vera: That threshold sounds like what we need to aim for in our pipelines—a compromise that keeps most of the signal while cutting out the most problematic noise.

Jocelyn: They also point out some differences between persistence measured in science observations and what you get from dark calibration data, suggesting they aren't identical.

Vera: Plus, they found that energetic particle hits, or EPHs, produce signals with lower amplitudes and faster decay compared to astronomical sources at similar signal levels.

Jocelyn: That’s significant because it means we can potentially use the persistence signal itself to help us distinguish between astrophysical sources and these particle events during data analysis.

Vera: And they observed that over the mission, the overall amplitude of this persistence signal has gradually decreased by roughly ten percent, which they link to repeated exposure of pixels to highly saturating stimuli.

Jocelyn: That gradual long-term decrease in amplitude is something we need to track, because it tells us about the cumulative effects on detector performance over time as the mission progresses.

Vera: If that trend continues, we might need a way to recalibrate persistence after oversaturations, because they noted that these events can induce long-lasting changes in persistence that could last for months with little temporal evolution.

Jocelyn: So, to summarize this paper on DR1 persistence in NISP detectors: it’s a complex, spatially varying noise source tied to the preceding signal level and time.

Vera: The key practical thing is that you need a flexible approach to modeling this decay, using both ground calibration and in-flight data to cover different timescales.

Jocelyn: And for the community, it means we have a better handle on the systematic uncertainties inherent in these infrared observations, which should help us get more robust constraints on cosmology.

Vera: We’ll keep an eye on how this model performs as we continue our science runs and see if those mitigation strategies actually cut that masked fraction down to the five percent level they mentioned.

Jocelyn: And we're eager to see how this persistence signal plays out when we start looking at those deeper, longer-term observations where the in-flight data model becomes most relevant.

Vera: It’s a good piece of work because it moves beyond just measuring the noise and gives us a concrete way to handle it, which is what we need to keep pushing for better constraints on dark energy or structure formation.

The paper's improvements: Vera: So, we’re talking about how the authors suggest they should improve their handling of this persistence noise in DR1 data.

Jocelyn: Right, so they aren't just describing the problem; they are giving us specific ways to fix it in practice.

Vera: They suggest developing a persistence model that combines ground-based characterization data for the fast components with in-flight data for tracking evolution over longer time scales.

Jocelyn: That means using both measurement sets together to get a better picture of how this noise behaves at different rates.

Vera: They also propose implementing a dynamic masking strategy that adapts based on both a fixed illumination history duration and a signal level threshold.

Jocelyn: Like they suggest using a three-hour illumination history combined with about five electrons to reduce the masked fraction down to below five percent while still suppressing those visible artifacts.

Vera: That sounds like a practical compromise that keeps most of the signal while cutting out the most problematic noise.

Jocelyn: They also talk about enhancing their ability to distinguish between astronomical sources and energetic particle hits, or EPHs, in the persistence signal.

Vera: They bring up the finding that EPH signals have lower amplitudes and decay faster than astronomical sources at comparable signal levels.

Jocelyn: So they want us to use this as a tool during analysis to help separate those two things during data processing.

Vera: And there’s another suggestion about integrating a history-aware correction mechanism into the pipeline, specifically by recalibrating persistence after oversaturations.

Jocelyn: That addresses the long-term changes they mentioned, suggesting these effects could last for months and need special handling beyond just short timescales.

Vera: They also suggest modeling the spatial variation of background amplitude to account for charge trapping and release effects, which can be below a few percent in detectors with high persistence.

Jocelyn: So they’re looking at everything from how they model the signal decay to how they correct for long-term detector aging and background noise.

Vera: This is really about building a more robust system for analyzing the Euclid data, moving past just describing what's wrong to actively fixing it in the pipeline.

Jocelyn: It sounds like this is about making sure that when we look at faint cosmological signals, we aren't just fighting detector artifacts but are using better models to account for them.

Vera: The implication here is that if these mitigation strategies work as they suggest, our error bars on things like dark energy or structure formation should get tighter.

Jocelyn: So the question now is, will these proposed fixes actually deliver that lower masked fraction we’re hoping for?

Conclusion: Vera: So we’ve covered how this paper on Euclid Data Release one persistence in NISP detectors looks at modeling that noise problem and what they suggest to fix it.

Jocelyn: It boils down to using both ground and in-flight data to build a better picture of the signal decay across different timescales.

Vera: They propose specific ways to mitigate this, like dynamic masking based on history duration and signal level thresholds, aiming for a masked fraction below five percent.

Jocelyn: And they also suggest incorporating history-aware corrections after oversaturations and using the persistence signal itself to help separate EPHs from actual astronomical sources.

Vera: It’s basically moving from just describing the noise to having a concrete set of tools for handling it in the data pipeline.

Jocelyn: That means if these fixes work, our error bars on cosmological measurements should get tighter, which is pretty important for structure formation studies.

Vera: The paper shows that persistence isn't just random noise; it’s a systematic artifact tied to how much signal came before it and where you are on the focal plane.

Jocelyn: It gives us a better handle on these systematics, but they also flag that the effectiveness of those mitigation strategies depends heavily on your chosen masking threshold and how long your illumination history model is.

Vera: And they pointed out that this persistence signal changes over time during the mission because of repeated exposures to bright stimuli.

Jocelyn: It’s a complex relationship, and getting those models right is going to be key for our next phases of data analysis.

Subrahmanyan: From a theoretical standpoint, better handling of these systematic errors means we can get cleaner constraints on the universe's expansion rate and structure growth.

Vera: Exactly. So, to wrap up this paper on Euclid Data Release one persistence in NISP detectors: it’s a complex, spatially varying noise source tied to the preceding signal level and time.

Jocelyn: And the key practical thing is that you need a flexible approach to modeling this decay, using both ground calibration and in-flight data to cover different timescales.

Vera: This is about building a more robust system for analyzing the Euclid data, moving past just describing what's wrong to actively fixing it in the pipeline.

Jocelyn: And for the community, it means we have a better handle on these systematics inherent in these infrared observations, which should help us get more robust constraints on cosmology.

Subrahmanyan: I think this work is important because if we can successfully model and mitigate this persistence, it gives us a cleaner shot at seeing the subtle effects of dark energy across vast scales.

Vera: We’ll keep an eye on how this model performs as we continue our science runs and see if those mitigation strategies actually cut that masked fraction down to the five percent level they mentioned.

Jocelyn: And we're eager to see how this persistence signal plays out when we start looking at those deeper, longer-term observations where the in-flight data model becomes most relevant.

Subrahmanyan: Next time, we’ll look at something completely different, maybe how those GaiaNIR spectrograph calculations are maximizing precision for radial velocities.

More episodes

← Home