AI and The Enclosure of the Scientific Commons

summary

The gist

The paper argues that artificial intelligence (AI) provides precisely the tools needed to enable a previously-infeasible enclosure of the information commons by turning shared resources into private…

In short

Artificial intelligence provides tools for an unprecedented enclosure of scientific and academic commons by allowing private actors to appropriate shared knowledge at massive scales. This process transforms public resources into private wealth, undermining existing social systems designed to nurture and protect open research.

Key concepts

Commons
Refers to shared resources like land or information that are used communally. Information commons are non-rivalrous and nonexcludable, making them resistant to traditional private property rules.
Enclosure Movement
Historically, this was the process where common lands were privatized, leading to the loss of traditional access rights for commoners and transforming shared resources into private assets.
Peer Production
This involves intentional effort where specialized expertise accumulates in a shared commons. The paper suggests that certain complex information goods are more efficiently produced this way than through market firms.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

AI and The Enclosure of the Scientific Commons · Read on arXiv

P. K. G. Williams

Center for Astrophysics | Harvard & Smithsonian

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics. The day in astrophysics: observations, models and what the data forces.

Vera: I'm Vera.

Jocelyn: And I'm Jocelyn, here with Subrahmanyan.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "AI and The Enclosure of the Scientific Commons".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper argues that artificial intelligence (AI) provides precisely the tools needed to enable a previously-infeasible enclosure of the information commons by turning shared resources into private wealth and undermining supporting social systems Historical Context of Commons and Enclosure Commons, in the sense of communally-owned land or other natural resources, have existed since antiquity and continue to exist in the present day This article’s analysis focuses on what are perhaps the most famous, and surely the best-studied, commons: the agricultural lands of feudal and preindustrial England In that system, the common land was understood to be owned by a local lord, but members of the local community could have rights to use the commons for activities such as agriculture, grazing, and the collection of firewood The destruction of the English commons was accomplished as part of what is known as the enclosure movement Over a span of centuries, ranging approximately from the 1600’s to the 1800’s, English lands, including the commons, were brought under a private property regime It generally resulted in commoners losing their traditional land access rights, leading to social unrest and an uprooted populace that gradually transformed into the factory workforce that powered the Industrial Revolution Enclosure was often interpreted as a confrontation between capitalism and traditional lifestyles In a word, enclosure was theft Modern Information Commons and Property Regimes While commons in the traditional sense are still studied, modern scholarship is often concerned with a non-traditional form: information commons In economic terms, information is unlike the pastures of yore in that it is non-rivalrous (if I’m using it, that doesn’t prevent you from using it as well) and nonexcludable (it is expensive to prevent someone from accessing and using it) These characteristics make information resistant to being subjected to a private-property regime, and correspondingly make it amenable to accumulation in a commons The concept of intellectual property (IP) and its associated legal framework is how our society attempts to integrate information into the property regime Over the course of the twentieth century, the scope of human creations that were treated as IP expanded dramatically, a phenomenon that has been called “the second enclosure movement” The general “cultural commons” largely exists outside of the property system, although the border is ambiguous The Role of Peer Production in Sustaining Commons Some information commons appear to arise spontaneously, but other information commons are the result of more intentional effort through commons-based peer production Benkler sought to understand the success of the open-source and Free Software movement Benkler’s core conclusion is that certain kinds of information goods — ones that require many small accumulations of diverse, specialized expertise to produce — are not just capable of being produced by loosely-organized groups of people tending to a commons; it is in fact more efficient to produce them this way than in markets or firms The key example of peer production in Benkler’s analysis is, of course, the open-source software community In science, the choice of who works on what task is largely decoupled from both market pricing and top-down control, and the results of that work accumulate in the broadly shared commons of the academic literature Scientists and scholars are commoners in a literal meaning that their way of life is bound to the commons, existing somewhat outside of the market system AI as a Tool for Unprecedented Enclosure Large Language Models could not exist without the commons because they are trained on the entire internet The training materials are responsible for most of the value of the models; the work that actually happens inside the offices of companies like OpenAI is, in comparison, incidental AI companies are incomparable defectors in Section 3 Exploitation of the information commons for profit can operate at what one might call “industrial scale” with AI (specifically, LLMs) This scaling-up comes hand-in-hand with a loss of any semblance of consent Generative AI therefore drives not just mass defection, but mass incompetence as well through “scholarslop” The analogy to fertilizer companies is cautioned against because research and scholarship are for the most part not profit-driven enterprises Implications for Scientific Labor AI is precisely the tool needed to launch an unprecedented enclosure of science, academia, and other information commons by enabling private actors to appropriate the enormous wealth held in the commons at previously unthinkable scales If robots are writing “papers” at rates 105–109 times faster than humans, it seems that the commons must detach from direct human management and comprehension altogether AI is precisely the tool needed to launch an unprecedented enclosure of science, academia, and other information commons The historian of technology Melvin Kranzberg articulated six “laws of technology” (M.

Vera: Kranzberg 1986), the first of which has the following form: Technology is neither good nor bad; nor is it neutral The ways in which people choose, or are coerced, to use and develop it are emphatically not neutral AI is precisely the tool needed to launch an unprecedented enclosure of science, academia, and other information commons The basic economic incentives seem to point to an answer in the affirmative regarding a new enclosure movement This article will not attempt to analyze AI from this viewpoint, but in this framework, scientists and scholars are no different than workers in any number of other industries that depend upon human expertise The perspective of enclosure helps underline that the most urgent concerns and discussions about AI really have little to do with its technical aspects The heart of the transgression is the same as historical enclosure, transforming common wealth into private gain at enormous scale If “theft” can be applied to anything broader than sample larceny, it applies here AI is precisely the tool needed to launch an unprecedented enclosure of science, academia, and other information commons It enables private actors to appropriate the enormous wealth held in the commons at previously unthinkable scales It simultaneously enables attacks upon the social systems that have evolved to grow, nurture, and protect those commons The basic economic incentives seem to point to an answer in the affirmative regarding a new enclosure movement The same is true of AI This article will not attempt to analyze AI from this viewpoint, but in this framework, scientists and scholars are no different than workers in any number of other industries that depend upon human expertise The perspective of enclosure helps underline that the most urgent concerns and discussions about AI really have little to do with its technical aspects The historian of technology Melvin Kranzberg articulated six “laws of technology” (M.

Jocelyn: Kranzberg 1986), the first of which has the following form: Technology is neither good nor bad; nor is it neutral Specific technologies do not have intrinsic moral content; but the ways that they are used in society absolutely do It is a category error (as well as a significant generalization) to say that AI is “good” or “bad” But the ways in which people choose, or are coerced, to use and develop it are emphatically not neutral This article opened with reference to the Luddites, but has focused on the commoners instead It is to be hoped that in the public discourse, a concern for the integrity of the commons, and resistance to attempts to steer them into private hands, help convey that more than mere self-interest and resistance to change are at stake The perspective of enclosure helps underline that the most urgent concerns and discussions about AI really have little to do with its technical aspects The same is true of AI This article will not attempt to analyze AI from this viewpoint, but in this framework, scientists and scholars are no different than workers in any number of other industries that depend upon human expertise The particulars of commons-based peer production are less relevant The fundamental distinction between skilled labor and capital is who owns the machines It is to be hoped that in the public discourse, a concern for the integrity of the commons, and resistance to attempts to steer them into private hands, help convey that more than mere self-interest and resistance to change are at stake The perspective of enclosure helps underline that the most urgent concerns and discussions about AI really have little to do with its technical aspects The same is true of AI This article will not attempt to analyze AI from this viewpoint, but in this framework, scientists and scholars are no different than workers in any number of other industries that depend upon human expertise The particulars of commons-based peer production are less relevant It is worth mentioning that in this interpretation the fundamental distinction between skilled labor and capital is who owns the machines Acknowledgments This article emerges from a presentation and discussion at the UCSD Software Citation Workshop, April 2026 PKGW thanks Rob Goodman and the Software Citation Workshop participants for helpful discussions, and Rosalind Williams for everything else For the record, this article was written without using generative AI tools PKGW just likes em-dashes Supporting research used Google and other search engines, which these days can reasonably be said to constitute “using AI” References Ansari, S.

Vera: 2026, Compound Deception in Elite Peer Review: A Failure Mode Taxonomy of 100 Fabricated Citations at NeurIPS 2025, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2602.05930, doi: 10.48550/arXiv.2602.05930 Arendt, H.

Title and authors: Vera: The title itself, "AI and The Enclosure of the Scientific Commons," suggests a direct link between this new technology and this historical process of taking shared resources privately.

Jocelyn: It really makes you think about how the pursuit of information might be fundamentally altered when AI can act as a powerful mechanism for appropriation.

Subrahmanyan: I wonder if we're talking about the same thing as the tragedy of the commons, or if this is a new type of enclosure entirely.

Vera: The paper suggests it’s not just about overuse leading to depletion, but about private actors gaining control over the entire scientific lifecycle through AI.

Jocelyn: It points out that generative AI models are trained on the entire internet, which means the training materials represent most of the value in those models.

Subrahmanyan: So if a few large companies control those training sets, they essentially own the infrastructure for generating new scientific knowledge at scale.

The paper's summary: Vera: The core argument is that AI gives private actors the means to appropriate the enormous wealth held in these information commons at scales we haven't seen before.

Jocelyn: It draws a parallel to how industrial-scale exploitation can happen with AI because of that scaling up, which brings a loss of any kind of consent into the picture.

Subrahmanyan: That loss of consent is what worries me from a cosmological standpoint; if private entities control the generation of models, they control what research gets done about things like structure formation.

Vera: The paper also mentions that this scaling leads to mass incompetence through something they call "scholarslop."

Jocelyn: They use an analogy to fertilizer companies being cautioned against, but the point is that research isn't usually profit-driven, so it’s not exactly the same as a commercial agricultural venture.

The paper's improvements: Vera: The authors suggest improving this view by looking at how AI can be used to create private workflows that bypass open access requirements for research papers.

Jocelyn: They propose a system where private actors could gain control of the underlying literature and aim to own the entire research lifecycle.

Subrahmanyan: That idea of owning the entire lifecycle would mean controlling not just the output, but also what gets considered valuable input for future discoveries.

Vera: The paper is also thinking about a way to manage peer production integration at an industrial scale, something that could prevent that scholarslop we talked about earlier.

Jocelyn: So they're suggesting an AI system that actively assesses potential contributions and rejects those deemed incompetent to defend the quality of shared knowledge.

Conclusion: Vera: To wrap up, the paper says the core transgression is transforming common wealth into private gain at enormous scales, which applies here because AI enables this appropriation.

Jocelyn: It enables private actors to appropriate wealth at previously unthinkable scales and simultaneously attacks the social systems that have grown to protect those commons.

Subrahmanyan: It boils down to the fundamental distinction between skilled labor and capital, which is who owns the machines that are doing the work.

Vera: The paper stresses that these discussions about AI really have little to do with its technical aspects, but rather with how people choose or are coerced in how they use it.

Jocelyn: It’s a reminder that even when we talk about scientific tools, the way we use them is not neutral.

Subrahmanyan: So the perspective of enclosure helps underline that the most urgent concerns about AI are really about protecting the integrity of the commons, not just its technical workings.

More episodes

← Home