A Multi-Cycle Treasury Survey of Andromeda: Comprehensive, All-Encompassing Spectroscopy, Imaging, and Mid-Infrared Mapping of the Nearest Giant Spiral

summary

The gist

We propose a Multi-Cycle Treasury program of ∼800 hours that would survey Andromeda the way the Milky Way has been surveyed by APOGEE, Gaia…

In short

A multi-cycle survey of Andromeda aims to create a comprehensive map of its stellar populations, star formation, and dust across various regions using NIRSpec spectroscopy and NIRCam imaging. The program will yield the first chemodynamical map of an L* galaxy other than the Milky Way, providing detailed insights into how stars form and evolve in this massive spiral.

Key concepts

Multi-Cycle Treasury Program
This is a long-term observational plan lasting about 800 hours spread over three cycles. It combines different instruments like NIRSpec and NIRCam to gather vast amounts of data on Andromeda, ensuring comprehensive coverage across its nucleus, bulge, disk, and halo.
Chemodynamical Map
This map integrates chemical information (element abundances) with dynamical information (velocities and ages). By measuring elements like C, N, O, and Fe in stars across different regions of Andromeda at high precision, researchers can understand how the galaxy's structure and star formation history are chemically linked.
$\alpha$-bimodality
This refers to a specific pattern observed in the ratio of alpha elements (like Mg) to iron (Fe) in stars. The survey will test this pattern across different parts of Andromeda, helping scientists understand the timing and speed at which different stellar populations formed within the galaxy.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

A Multi-Cycle Treasury Survey of Andromeda: Comprehensive, All-Encompassing Spectroscopy, Imaging, and Mid-Infrared Mapping of the Nearest Giant Spiral · Read on arXiv

David M. Nataf, David L. Nidever, Gagandeep Anand, Magda Arnaboldi, Joss Bland-Hawthorn, Scott Call, Santi Cassisi, Marcio Catelan, Julianne Dalcanton, Ivanna Escala, Mario Gennaro, Â Benjamin Gibson, Á Karoline Gilbert, Á Michael Hayden, Á Danny Horta, о Caroline Huang, Rodrigo Ibata, Christian Johnson, Evan Kirby, Chiaki Kobayashi, Andrea Kunder, Geraint Lewis, о Anna Liptrottt⵹, М Massimo Marengo, Melissa Ness, Rachel Pauline, Henry Prager, Zdenek Prudil, Henrique Reggiani, Michael Rich, Ricardo Schiavon, Sanjib Sharma, Brian Thorsbro, о Yuan-Sen Ting, Dan Weisz, Rosemary Wyse, Н Gail Zasowski, and Catherine Zucker

University of Iowa · Montana State University

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics. The day in astrophysics: observations, models and what the data forces.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "A Multi-Cycle Treasury Survey of Andromeda".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. We propose a Multi-Cycle Treasury program of ∼800 hours that would survey Andromeda the way the Milky Way has been surveyed by APOGEE, Gaia, and WISE The result would be the first chemodynamical, star-formation, and dust map of an L⋆ galaxy other than our own built from individual stars, at a scale no single-cycle program can reach Scientific Justification Andromeda is an L⋆ galaxy like the Milky Way but quite distinct from the Milky Way It carries about twice the stellar mass ∼ 10 13 M⊙ yet forms stars at a fraction of the Milky Way’s rate It had a major merger ∼2 Gyr ago whose debris is the Giant Stellar Stream and whose remnant may be M32 It hosts ∼450 globular clusters against our ∼ 180 Its central black hole is 20 to 30× more massive than Sgr A∗ and is inside a composite bulge whose classical component the Milky Way lacks Finally, its center emits gamma rays at eight times the rate of a Milky Way scaling What the Stars Record Corecollapse supernovae enrich the interstellar medium with α elements within a few 10 7 yr of a star formation event, whereas Type Ia supernovae supply most of the iron over 10 8 − 10 9 yr timescales A population that formed quickly is αenhanced at every metallicity, one that formed slowly turns over toward solar ratios once Type Ia enrichment catches up This clock, read from

α/Fe: yields the prediction that bulges and ellipticals formed in early, rapid bursts The stars of ellipticals, where these prediction matters most, cannot be resolved Scientific Scope of the Survey The survey aims to measure C, N, O, Mg, Si, Ca, Ti, Al, Na, K, Fe and other elements to ≲0.05 dex per star This precision exceeds what is necessary to distinguish two sequences analogous to the Milky Way’s in a sample large enough to ask the question separately in the bulge, inner and outer disk, minor axis, and halo Dynamics will yield the first age–velocity dispersion relation outside the Milky Way from the nucleus to 29 kpc Star-formation history will be extended into the infrared and beyond the PHAT footprint Dust mapping will map PAH and warm-dust emission at 1–3 pc resolution over 450 arcmin2 Survey Design The survey is built of two unit classes, the first being a “brick" of three fields A, B, and C in a row along the NIRSpec-to-NIRCam offset A standard brick costs 58 h charged and returns up to ∼500 stars with spectra The layout includes twelve bricks, two in the nucleus (0.5 kpc), six along the major axis at 3, 8, 13, 19, 24, and 29 kpc NIRSpec uses G140H/F100LP and G235M/F170LP with three MSA configurations dithered in the dispersion direction by 0, 80, and 160 shutters Feasibility GO-2609 showed that G140H/F100LP on the MSA yields S/N 78 per pixel at 1.4 mag below the tip Our MARCS-based synthetic spectra of M giants give a census in Table 2 The program requires 804 h over three cycles to produce a catalog of ∼4,500 stars with abundances, velocities, and ages The products include a catalog of ∼4,500 stars with abundances, velocities, and ages; ten-band photometry of ∼20 million stars with photometric

Fe/H: and

α/Fe: calibrated on the spectra; two-epoch photometry of the Cepheids and Miras; and MIRI maps of the PAH and warm-dust emission The program executes in the winter visibility windows (V3PA 82◦–104◦) at 230–310 h per cycle Why a Multi-Cycle Treasury Program Three things put this survey beyond single-cycle programs The first is scale, requiring 370 h of NIRSpec time before any imaging for a 4,500-star sample at S/N 80 The second is geometry, as MSA configurations and MIRI parallels line up only at the roll angles of M31’s winter window The third reason is uniformity, as archival programs differ in selection, depth, and gratings The Prevalence of the α-bimodality Figure 3 shows

α/Fe: against

Fe/H: for upper-RGB stars in the outer disk of M31 from our Bayesian isochrone fits to archival NIRCam photometry Fewer bands, shallower exposures, and fewer dithers than proposed here already resolve a metal-rich concentration near solar metallicity and a metal-poor, αricher tail The statistical uncertainties from Doppler are <∼ 8 km s−1 indicating that the scatter is still dominated by systematics Abundances We used FERRE to determine the stellar parameters, metallicity and αabundance The 4-D grid in Teff, log g,

M/H: and

α/M: was generated for wavelengths 9,000–18,000 Å using the Synspec spectral synthesis package with Kurucz model atmospheres The element abundances are detailed in Table 2 Dynamics Radial velocities to a few km s−1 for the same stars, with ages from

C/N: , give the first age–velocity dispersion relation outside the Milky Way The strong correlation indicates that there is an RV offset due to the position of the stars in the “slit” The corrected RV histogram shows a significantly reduced scatter of 8 km s−1 Star-formation History The NIRCam mosaics reach the red clump in ten filters from 0.9 to 4.6 µm over 1,600 arcmin2, extending the PHAT star-formation histories into the infrared and beyond the PHAT footprint Our Bayesian isochrone fits to the archival NIRCam photometry already resolve the

α/Fe: –

Fe/H: distribution of the outer disk Dust MIRI imaging maps the PAH and warm-dust emission that Herschel and Spitzer see only at coarser resolution at 1–3 pc resolution over 450 arcmin2 The NIRCam colors of the bright giants give the corresponding dust extinction curve and normalization Variable Stars Every field is imaged twice, a year apart, and each receives two-epoch NIRCam photometry in up to ten filters The Miras and Cepheids in the brick fields receive NIRSpec spectra with the spectroscopically anchored O-rich/Crich classification The Halo The minor-axis and outermost bricks reach the inner halo, where Hong et al.

Paper summary: Vera: We’ve seen the plan for this Multi-Cycle Treasury Survey of Andromeda: Comprehensive, All-Encompassing Spectroscopy, Imaging, and Mid-Infrared Mapping of the Nearest Giant Spiral. It’s a program designed to survey Andromeda in a way we’ve done for the Milky Way with APOGEE, Gaia, and WISE.

Jocelyn: The authors claim this will be the first chemodynamical, star-formation, and dust map of an L star galaxy other than our own built from individual stars. That’s a massive claim because it means we’re building something entirely new for Andromeda.

Subrahmanyan: What matters here is that the scale they are reaching is beyond what a single-cycle program can achieve. They want to measure elements like carbon, nitrogen, oxygen, magnesium, silicon, calcium, titanium, aluminum and sodium and potassium.

Vera: They aim for a precision of less than zero point zero five dex per star on those elements. That precision is needed to distinguish between two sequences analogous to the Milky Way’s in a sample large enough to ask that question separately in the bulge, inner disk, outer disk, minor axis, and halo.

Jocelyn: They are also looking at dynamics and star formation history. Dynamics will yield the first age velocity dispersion relation outside the Milky Way from the nucleus all the way out to twenty nine kiloparsecs.

Subrahmanyan: That age velocity dispersion relation is key because it connects stellar populations to their kinematics across different regions of Andromeda, which helps us understand how galaxies assemble over time.

Vera: The star formation history will be extended into the infrared and beyond the PHAT footprint using those NIRCam mosaics to reach the red clump in ten filters from zero point nine to four point six micrometers.

Jocelyn: And they’ve got dust mapping too, which maps PAH and warm-dust emission at a one to three parsec resolution over that four hundred arcminutes area. It’s going beyond what we typically see with coarser resolution instruments like Herschel or Spitzer.

Subrahmanyan: So, in short, the paper is about using this multi-cycle program to build a complete picture—chemistry, dynamics, star formation history and dust—of Andromeda at a scale no single survey can reach.

Conclusion: Vera: Looking at the title of this paper, "A Multi-Cycle Treasury Survey of Andromeda: Comprehensive, All-Encompassing Spectroscopy, Imaging, and Mid-Infrared Mapping of the Nearest Giant Spiral," it really sums up the sheer scale they are attempting.

Jocelyn: It’s about doing a comprehensive survey across multiple instruments over many cycles to get this detailed picture of Andromeda. It’s a huge undertaking for one galaxy.

Subrahmanyan: The implication is that we are moving toward building models for other L star galaxies based on real, individual stars, rather than just relying on general statements about how galaxies form.

Vera: They are using the precise measurements from spectroscopy and imaging to map out the chemical and physical properties of Andromeda across its entire structure. That’s a lot of data points for one target.

Jocelyn: It gives us a new way to look at galaxy evolution by connecting stellar ages, element abundances, and dust distribution in a single dataset for this specific galaxy.

Subrahmanyan: The authors are addressing the ambiguity around things like the alpha-bimodality in bulges, which they link to rapid star formation bursts or gas-rich mergers. This survey data could test those specific models against a real galaxy instead of just simulations.

Vera: So, this isn't just about getting better data on Andromeda; it’s about testing the fundamental physics of how galaxies evolve in the local universe by using Andromeda as a benchmark.

More episodes

← Home